Why was India’s second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic so fierce?

On this article, writes Vidya S Sharma, Ph.D., I want (a) to focus on the ferocity of the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in India; (b) why the Modi Administration carried out so poorly; and (c) how properly India ready for the third wave?

Happily, the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in India appears to be ebbing but it surely provides me no pleasure to remind the readers that final Could, in my article I discussed India was a time bomb ready to blow up.

Previously twelve months, the scenario in India has not solely worsened past my worst situation. Modi bragged on the World Financial Discussion board on 28 January that India “has saved the world, complete humanity, from a serious tragedy by successfully controlling coronavirus”. The fact is that India has now grow to be a safety risk to the remainder of the world, particularly the free world.

The pandemic has introduced untold distress to the underside 600 million Indians who’ve misplaced a number of of their relations to COVID-19, or having exhausted all their life’s financial savings or mortgaged all their valuables, financially have been set again by a era or two, now stay unemployed in an underperforming economic system with no significant help from the Central/State Governments, or have grow to be depending on their mother and father, relations and buddies.

Determine 1: Exams per confirmed case in India and neighbouring nations
Supply: Our World in Information

There are tens of hundreds of households which have misplaced the only real breadwinner to the pandemic. Hundreds of youngsters have been rendered orphans having misplaced each of their mother and father to Covid-19. Scholar studying has been set again by greater than a yr. It’s a man-made catastrophic calamity.

The underside 600 million might have suffered silently and buried their useless alongside the financial institution of the River Ganga or thrown their useless our bodies within the river itself (for they may not afford the price of cremating the useless). However the virus has not spared what are termed lower- and upper-middle-class households in India.

In response to an investigative report commissioned by The Indian Specific: “Throughout the nation, many might have efficiently overwhelmed the virus, however their lives have been upended by the loans they must repay courtesy of giant Covid-19 medical payments. They’ve dipped into years of financial savings, offered jewelry, mortgaged property, and borrowed from buddies to clear the medical payments.”

Earlier than I’m going any additional let me recount just a few of the errors of the Modi administration that I listed in my article of Could 2020.

The primary confirmed case of COVID-19 in India was reported on January 30, 2020.

By then it was well-known how infectious and deadly the COVID-19 (or SARS-CoV-2) virus was. Per week earlier on 23 January, the Chinese language authorities had quarantined Wuhan (the town broadly thought-about as its supply) and by January 25 all the province of Hubei was in lockdown. Australia banned flights from China on 1 February and some days after it closed its skies to worldwide airways.

These developments ought to have rung alarm bells in India which has a really poor well being infrastructure. The WHO recommends a ratio of a minimal of 1 physician to 1000 sufferers. India has 0.67 docs for each 1,000 individuals. The identical determine for China is 1.8. For the 2 nations most severely affected in March-April, 2020 by COVID-19, ie, Spain and Italy, this determine is 4.1.

Private hygiene (ie, washing arms with clear water and cleaning soap commonly) is strongly really helpful as the primary line of precautionary defence towards this virus. On this regard, it’s price noting that fifty.7% of the agricultural inhabitants doesn’t have primary hand-washing services in India. The identical determine for the city inhabitants was 20.2% and round 40.5 per cent for the inhabitants general.

Determine 2: COVID-19 and black market profiteering
Supply: Statista and BBC

As late as early March 2020, the Modi Authorities was not finishing up any temperature checks even of the worldwide arrivals. It closed its airspace to worldwide airways solely on March 14 (six weeks later than Australia did and seven weeks after Beijing locked down all the province of Hubei).

As a substitute of taking any steps to include the unfold of the COVID-19, ie, to guard the well being of India’s residents, Prime Minister Modi and his administration busied themselves organising large “Namaste Trump” rallies in New Delhi and Ahmadabad (Gujarat) for the forthcoming go to of President Trump. In different phrases, Modi most well-liked a second of glory and worldwide TV protection for himself at the price of the well being of his countrymen.

When it turned clear to New Delhi that the scenario was uncontrolled, the Modi Authorities freaked and on March 24 declared a 21 days India-wide lockdown at 3 hours’ discover. This was later prolonged for one more 3 weeks.

No planning went into it. Even all the public transport community was grounded.

The underside half of the inhabitants of India (approx. 600 million) are very poor or stay beneath the poverty line (between them they share solely 2.5% of the nation’s wealth whereas the highest 1% personal 77% of the nation’s wealth). These individuals are each day wage earners with no entitlement to annual/sick/maternity depart or pension/superannuation. It didn’t happen to anybody within the Modi Authorities how would they feed themselves or their households in the course of the 6-week lockdown?

Because of this panic transfer, we noticed unhappy, distressing, appalling pictures of stranded migrant employees (approx. 200 million) making an attempt to stroll house (in some circumstances as many as 600-700 kilometres) with none entry to meals, water, sanitary services or shelter.

Sadly, the lockdown solely postponed the inevitable. Through the lockdown interval, the Modi Authorities didn’t do primary preparatory work. Neither testing stations nor any isolation centres had been arrange even within the greatest Indian cities. On 4 April 2020, The Indian Specific uncovered that between 20,000 to 30,000 ventilators had been mendacity dysfunctional throughout the nation in numerous hospitals for need of elements or servicing. Even in main hospitals in massive cities, there was barely any private protecting tools (PPE).

On 8 April 2020, in a submission to the Supreme Court docket (the apex court docket in India), the Modi Authorities conceded that it couldn’t conduct greater than 15,000 COVID-19 checks per day.

Equally, barely any try was made to teach the inhabitants on the significance of social distancing and private hygiene or advise them of the fundamental signs of Covid-19. No try was ever made to clarify the pandemic administration technique to most of the people or the Parliament. No steps had been taken to cease profiteering by conscience-less opportunistic companies.


Regardless of being greater than a yr into the pandemic, the speed of testing in India stays abysmally low.

The WHO pointers state that for each confirmed case 10-30 individuals must be examined relying upon the density of inhabitants, the typical variety of individuals within the family, hygienic situations prevailing round them, and many others.

Given the WHO pointers, India must be testing near 25-30 individuals per confirmed case. However as Determine 1 beneath reveals in early Could 2021 when India was reporting round 400,000 new confirmed circumstances daily. It follows that India ought to have been testing round 10 to 12 million individuals daily. But it surely was testing round 4.5 individuals for each new confirmed case. This was decrease than its neighbours: Bangladesh (9 individuals/confirmed case) Pakistan (10.5 individuals/case), Sri Lanka (13/confirmed case).

Determine 3: Vaccine doses administered throughout ‘Vaccine Competition’ The Wire
Supply: and The Wire

Thus the Modi Administration, even after residing with the pandemic for greater than a yr, appears to not be making any critical effort to find out the extent of group transmission in India.

Not solely India is just not conducting sufficient checks for COVID-19 to find out the extent of group transmission, however in lots of cases checks are performed by inadequately educated and unaccredited professionals. The Covid-19 take a look at most generally carried out in India has a excessive error charge (as a lot as 30%). The accuracy of information collected by the Indian Authorities is additional compromised as a result of in lots of circumstances the testers are utilizing understrength or impure chemical compounds or contaminated tools/chemical compounds.


Mainstream media in India, notably tv and radio (and particularly radio stations and TV channels which are both owned by the Central Authorities or by enterprise homes or politicians with shut hyperlinks to the BJP and its many sister organisations) haven’t made any effort to make the Modi Administration accountable for its failure to competently handle the pandemic.

It could be naïve to count on that media retailers owned by politicians elected with the BJP’s help or pro-BJP people or organisations would take Modi to account or search transparency in decision-making. These retailers stay as sycophantic as ever.

Additional, New Delhi is the nation’s greatest advertiser. The Modi Administration alone spent about $270,000 on commercials daily in 2019 to 2020 monetary yr. The Modi authorities, similar to Mrs Gandhi did throughout her rule, has been punishing media homes (eg, NDTV, The Wire, The Print, and many others.) by blacklisting them from getting promoting from the federal government departments, statutory our bodies or Public Sector Enterprise Enterprises. This has meant some media retailers that had been crucial of the BJP Authorities have been compelled to close their doorways. It has been broadly reported that the Modi authorities has additionally been placing strain on numerous firms to not promote in newspapers and on TV channels which are crucial of the BJP Authorities.

To stifle its criticism, the Hindu Nationalist BJP governments have gone additional than Mrs Gandhi ever did. They’ve arrested journalists, actors, movie administrators, authors on trumped-up fees (eg, starting from sedition, tax evasion, to endangering nationwide safety, to defaming numerous BJP leaders, to bringing unhealthy title to India, and many others.) or just demonising them as individuals engaged in anti-national actions.

The first motive the mainstream media has been prepared to kowtow to the Modi administration is that the majority media retailers in India are owned by enterprise homes which are chaebols, ie, they’re industrial conglomerates with pursuits in lots of different sectors. They are not looking for their different enterprise pursuits to be damage by an unfavourable legislative surroundings or the federal government pursuing them for non-payment of taxes, or some minor international foreign money legislation violation, and many others.


To suppress the true loss of life toll, the Modi Administration consciously took some coverage choices very early on:

First, anyone who dies in a hospital however was not examined for Covid 19 earlier than being admitted, is just not counted as a Covid-19 fatality.

Second, these sufferers who might have been examined Covid-19 optimistic however suffered already from different diseases (eg, hypertension, diabetes, lung an infection, irregular heartbeat, broken kidneys, and many others.) then they don’t seem to be counted as Covid-19 fatalities.

Third, anyone who dies of Covid 19 however didn’t die in a hospital, is just not counted as a Covid-19 fatality. It’s price recalling that every one private and non-private hospitals had been overwhelmed within the first few weeks of the pandemic in early 2020. So a overwhelming majority of the Covid-19 fatalities fall on this class.



The pandemic has straight affected almost each household in India. The scenario is getting worse. The individuals on the street realize it.

The mainstream media has realised that it can not gloss over the Modi Administration failures and lack of motion on this situation. This case has compelled a few of the media retailers to alter their tune. They know if they don’t do clarify what is going on within the nation and why it’s taking place then they are going to start to lose readership/viewers leading to lack of income.

On this connection, I cite merely a handful of examples beneath.

Om Gaur is the nationwide editor of Dainik Bhaskar, an Indian Hindi-language each day newspaper with a each day circulation of 4.6 million. In response to the Audit Bureau of Circulations, it ranks third on the planet by circulation and the primary in India.

Gaur obtained a tip from one in every of his readers that useless our bodies had been seen floating the River Ganga River within the state of Bihar.

These useless our bodies had been severely decomposed so police in Bihar thought they’d come from upstream, presumably from Uttar Pradesh. Gaur despatched a crew of 30 reporters to over 27 districts located alongside the banks of the River Ganga to research the matter.

These reporters, inside just a few hours, situated greater than 2,000 our bodies that had been both floating within the river or have been buried in shallow graves alongside a 1,100-kilometre stretch of the River Ganga. It’s not unreasonable to imagine that had they investigated the matter additional they might have discovered many extra corpses.

Determine 4: India’s Ministry of AYUSH suggestions to combat COVID-19
Supply: Authorities of India and BBC Information

Their enquiries additionally revealed these our bodies belonged to Hindu households too poor to cremate their useless relations. None of those deaths will likely be counted as COVID-19 fatalities by the Indian Authorities.

My enquiries in a big authorities hospital in Lucknow (capital of Uttar Pradesh) discovered that in a sure interval in April 2021, COVID-19 deaths amounted to greater than 220 however solely 21 had been reported as deaths on account of COVID-19.

Australia’s business channel 9 confirmed footage during which ambulance workers look like throwing useless our bodies of COVID-19 victims within the River Ganga.

In Gujarat (house state of Modi), the next three Gujarati-language newspapers are most generally learn: Sandesh, Samachar and Divya Bhaskar (owned by the identical group that owns Dainik Bhakar). All three have constantly questioned the official statistics.

Divya Bhaskar despatched its correspondents to varied authorities departments, municipal firms, hospitals and crematoria. Its investigations revealed that by the center of Could 2021 round 124,000 loss of life certificates had been issued within the prior 71 days in Gujarat. This determine was about 66,000 greater than throughout the identical interval final yr. The state authorities reported that solely 4,218 had been associated to Covid. In different phrases, the BJP authorities in Gujarat was undercounting COVID-19 fatalities by an element of 20 instances or extra.

Divya Bhaskar’s journalists talked with relations of victims and docs and found that many of the latest deaths had been attributed to underlying situations or co-morbidities.

However even these findings, howsoever horrifying image they could paint, don’t seize the extent of group infections and the devastation the pandemic is inflicting in India.

Sukma is a district is within the state of Chhattisgarh, some of the backward states in India. Sukma is dominated by Maoist insurgents known as Naxalites. Inside Sukma district lies a tiny village, Karma Gondi. The latter, greater than 25 km from the closest freeway, is enclosed by a forest. Within the third week of Could, ie, a couple of month in the past, almost one out of three individuals examined on this village — 91 of 239 — have examined optimistic for the coronavirus.

If in such a distant village 38% of the inhabitants is contaminated then it will not be unreasonable to imagine nationally the determine can be a lot larger.


Early this yr, between 17 December and eight January, two weeks earlier than India commenced its vaccination programme, the Indian Council of Medical Analysis (ICMR) performed a nationwide serum survey, the third of its variety. It discovered that greater than 21% of India’s grownup inhabitants have been uncovered to COVID-19.

In a serum survey, the immunologists look at the liquid a part of blood, or ‘serum’, to detect if the chosen particular person reveals an immune response to the viral materials, not SARS-CoV-2 virus materials itself, ie, are there antibodies in his/her blood.

Within the above nationwide survey, involving 28,589 individuals, the ICMR discovered that greater than 21% of India’s grownup inhabitants have been uncovered to Covid-19

On 4 February, the Director-Basic of the ICMR, Balram Bhargava, informed a press convention that the serum survey confirmed that the presence of Covid-19 antibodies in youngsters aged 10 to 17 years was 25.3%.

Whereas the above nationwide survey concerned a small pattern (given the dimensions of the inhabitants of India) such surveys have been performed in a number of massive cities.

These serum surveys indicated that Covid 19 had touched 56% of the inhabitants in Delhi by January 2021, 75% in some slums of Mumbai (November 2020) and about 30% in Bengaluru (beforehand often called Bangalore) in November 2020.


Within the absence of any effort undertaken by the pro-business BJP authorities to make sure that the companies don’t profiteer excessively, it’s price noting that not solely the value of cremation however of all of the medicines prescribed to combat Covid-19 an infection, oxygen cylinders, and many others. have skyrocketed throughout India and most crematoria have a ready record of minimal 2-3 days.

The unchecked profiteering and corruption begin with each Indian vaccine producers: The Serum Institute of India (SII) and Bharat Biotech (BB).

Let me first inform the readers that each firms had been assisted significantly both by international charities or New Delhi: the SII acquired US$ 300 million from Invoice and Melinda Gates Basis to do developmental analysis and arrange manufacturing services. It manufactures the Astra Zeneca vaccine below the title of Covishield.

The Modi Administration offered large help to BB in any respect phases of its Covaxine growth and manufacture.

In different phrases, these firms have taken minimal threat both within the growth of their vaccine or in organising manufacturing services.

The SII has a three-tier value construction: the unit value for New Delhi is INR 150; the state governments are charged INR 300 (initially Rs 400 however lowered later) and personal hospitals pay INR 600. Covaxin costs are INR 150, INR 400 and INR 1,200, respectively

On the present change charge, the Serum Institute of India’s value for state governments (Rs 300) interprets to $4.00 per unit. Its unit value to non-public hospitals interprets to $8. However AstraZeneca fees $2.18 per dose to the European Union and $4 to the US. In different phrases, the Indian costs are a lot larger than the costs for the EU and the US. That is so regardless that the manufacturing and logistics prices are a lot decrease in India than in Europe and the US.

Profiteering has been taken to much more obscene ranges by Bharat Biotech. The latter is reported to have very shut hyperlinks with the ruling BJP.

These firms couldn’t have overpriced their merchandise with out the Modi Administration’s connivance.

Given the devastating severity of the second wave of the Covid 19 pandemic in India, each firms have introduced plans to double their manufacturing capability. Once more it’s New Delhi that’s funding the enlargement plans of those firms, ie, shareholders of each firms will profit significantly however should not bearing any threat.

Scammers and politically linked individuals are promoting hospital beds, drugs, oxygen and different provides at exorbitant costs as they prey on the desperation and grief of households.

Xavier Minz, the proprietor of the biggest non-public lab in Bilaspur, informed Asia Instances: “It’s time for me to make good on the losses I suffered when most hospitals had been shut (as a result of lockdown in March 2020). I obtained permission to do the Covid Actual-Time PCR lab [test] and may cost 3,800 rupees towards my bills of 1,100 rupees for a single take a look at.”

Concerning profiteering and corruption regarding the pandemic, Arundhati Roy, a political activist however higher identified within the West as a novelist, wrote within the Wire,

“There are markets for different issues, too. On the backside finish of the free market, a bribe to sneak a final take a look at the one you love, bagged and stacked in a hospital mortuary. A surcharge for a priest who agrees to say the ultimate prayers. On-line medical consultancies during which determined households are fleeced by ruthless docs. On the prime finish, you may must promote your land and residential and expend each final rupee for remedy at a non-public hospital. Simply the deposit alone, earlier than they even conform to admit you, might set your loved ones again a few generations.”

On Could 6, 2021, a choose of the Delhi Excessive Court docket commented that “the ethical material of the general public had been dismantled”.

When interviewed by a The New York Instances reporter, Vikram Singh, a former police chief in Uttar Pradesh, commented, “I’ve seen every kind of predators and all types of depravity, however this degree of predation and depravity I’ve not seen within the 36 years of my profession or in my life.”


They have interaction in public relations gimmicks and mendacity as a result of they’re afraid to degree with the Indian populace. In a speech final week, Prime Minister Modi claimed that until he took workplace in 2014 solely 60 per cent of India had been vaccinated. If that had been so how then polio and smallpox have been eradicated from India?

When the second wave was at its peak, not having the ability to face the fact and to distract the individuals, Modi stated got here out with one other of his gimmicks and photograph alternative:

Throughout a gathering with the chief ministers on 8 April 2021, PM Modi introduced that ‘Tika Utsav’ (= vaccination competition) will likely be noticed between 11 April-14 April (inclusive) the place individuals will likely be vaccinated en masse. On the identical press convention, Modi lied that “we defeated the primary Covid with out vaccines.”

The members of his process power took their cue from their supreme chief and indulged in even greater lies. They claimed they anticipated everybody to be vaccinated by December 2021. 60% of Indians (Whole inhabitants = 1326 million) are above the age of 20 years. It means India would wish round 2 billion doses of vaccine(s) to inoculate 60% of its inhabitants.

No one within the BJP defined how would they procure the required doses of vaccines earlier than December 2021? How are they going to get them into individuals’s arms? How would they overcome the scarcity of uncooked materials presently plaguing vaccine producers worldwide?

I’ve extensively travelled within the Hindi belt states (the heartland of the BJP). I do know as a truth lots of the main well being care centres, similar to main colleges, solely exist on paper. Hospitals in small cities and cities and rural areas wouldn’t have steady energy and water provide. Many of those hospitals should not stored clear. So the place would these vaccine doses be saved? The place are educated individuals to manage them?

How efficient was this vaccination competition? Not very a lot, if we go by the proof.

The variety of vaccine doses in the course of the vaccination competition (ie, April 11 to April 14) was lower than different days in April (see Determine 3).

In response to, 29,33,418 new vaccine doses had been administered on April 11, significantly lower than for April 8 (41,35,589), April 9 (37,40,898) and April 10 (35,19,987).

On April 12, 40,04,520 vaccine doses got, however on April 13, the quantity dropped down by 33% to 26,46,493 doses. On April 14, the variety of doses given stood at 33,13,660.

In different phrases, it was only a public relations gimmick to befool the general public that the Modi Authorities was busy doing one thing to sort out the second wave.

All people on the planet has identified India is affected by a extreme scarcity of oxygen cylinders and tanks, ventilators, hospital beds, medicines, and many others. But the Modi administration demanded that Fb and Twitter take away such offending posts as a result of they amounted to spreading misinformation.

On Could 13, 2021, in New Delhi, police arrested 9 individuals for allegedly pasting posters that criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi concerning the botched up COVID-19 vaccination drive.

In regards to the time when the second wave of the pandemic was gathering energy, on March 7, 2021, Union Well being Minister, Harsh Vardhan declared: “We’re in the long run recreation of the Covid 19 in India”

Then on March 30 2021, when the ferocity of the second wave was changing into clearer, Harsh Vardhan once more lied to the Indians and claimed: “The scenario is below management.”

To date a bit of over 2% (two per cent) of the inhabitants has been vaccinated.



The precise to freedom of speech is assured within the Indian Structure below Article 19(1)(a). However this freedom is just not absolute and Article 19(2) lists sure restrictions in order that the suitable of free speech is exercised responsibly.

With relations dying due to scarcity of oxygen, drugs, ventilators, empty oxygen cylinders, unavailability of beds in hospitals – whether or not non-public or public, with scammers and black entrepreneurs fleecing them by preying on their distress, unable to discover a crematorium that will burn the useless physique as a result of all had been busy 24 hours burning hundreds of our bodies and charging an exorbitant sum of money, some Indians resorted to social media (eg, Fb, Twitter, and many others.) to hunt assist and vent their heartache and grief.

A political get together and its leaders with democratic tendencies would have admitted to their errors in dealing with the pandemic, apologised to the grieving nation, put in new personnel identified for his or her competence in dealing with the disaster (similar to pure disasters cyclones and floods, and many others.), reshuffled his/her cupboard, demoted or sacked incompetent ministers, made an effort to hunt recommendation from the scientists who knew how the virus behaved in different nations and what preventive measures these nations had taken, and promised the nation to do every thing to right the scenario.

However not one of the above occurred. As a substitute, the BJP leaders each in New Delhi and in numerous states resorted to stifle the criticism and unfold misinformation themselves.

Whereas sufferers had been gasping for breath and dying from suffocation on account of oxygen scarcity, on April 25, 2021, Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister, Ajay Mohan Bisht (popularly often called Yogi Adityanath) has requested officers to take motion below the Nationwide Safety Act and seize the property of people who had been spreading misinformation concerning oxygen scarcity on social media and he asserted: “No oxygen scarcity in any COVID hospital.”

As a substitute of behaving like India’s Putin or Xi Jinping, one would have anticipated that being a holy man he would have some respect for fact and present some humility and compassion. However no apology was made. Politics once more triumphed over the well being of residents.

Of dozens of media stories and hundreds of posts on Fb and Twitter, I quote solely three beneath.

On 22 April, The Quint reported how a number of hospitals in Lucknow (capital of Uttar Pradesh) had been dealing with an acute scarcity of oxygen cylinders. This record included The Mayo Hospital and Make Effectively Hospital and Trauma Centre.

On 27 April, reported that due to a scarcity of oxygen, sufferers had been dying like flies in jap Uttar Pradesh’s Ballia district.

Equally, India Right this moment on 28 April (usually a Modi-leaning media outlet) reported that 7 or 8 COVID-19 sufferers died at Paras Hospital in Agra “on account of acute scarcity of beds and medical oxygen.”

Whereas sufferers had been gasping for breath, the BJP senior leaders and Cupboard Ministers in New Delhi had been spreading false data by way of social media (I check with toolkit controversy) to discredit the Congress get together.

When the Congress Get together complained to Twitter stating that the alleged toolkit was faux and cast letterheads had been used within the screenshots. Twitter performed an inner investigation, utilizing expertise and unbiased third-party experience, and located that the ‘toolkit’ was cast and tagged the submit as ‘Manipulated Media’ the Central Authorities despatched the police to raid Twitter workplaces in New Delhi and Gurgaon to intimidate Twitter workers.

To not communicate of tolerating any public criticism, the BJP leaders can not even tolerate strategies made to them privately. This was evident from a impolite and offensive reply despatched by Well being Minister Harsh Vardhan to former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh who had dared to pen a letter to Mr Modi on find out how to combat the pandemic.

The Modi Administration and different BJP leaders’ try and silence the criticism earned a rebuke from the White Home when Biden’s Press Secretary Jen Psaki commented, “India’s on-line censorship is just not aligned with US view of freedom of speech.”

At house, the Supreme Court docket (India’s apex court docket) on 30 April said that it was conscious of the problems associated to the scarcity of oxygen, drug, and vaccine coverage in regards to the COVID-19 pandemic, and said there shouldn’t be any clampdown on the knowledge.

Justice Chandrachud went on to claim that “We’ll deal with it as contempt of court docket if such grievances are thought-about for motion.”

Whereas the BJP leaders are wanting to silence strange individuals from expressing their frustrations and grievances, it ignores the misinformation being unfold by its members of the Parliament and Ministry of Ayush web site (see Determine 4 beneath).

In BJP-run Manipur state, police arrested a journalist and an activist below the Nationwide Safety Act (it permits an individual to be detained for as much as a yr with out trial), after they posted on their respective Fb pages that cow urine and dung don’t treatment COVID-19

Pragya Thakur, a BJP MP from Madhya Pradesh (she first gained worldwide notoriety by stating that Mahatma Gandhi’s murderer was a patriot) not too long ago claimed that she was not contaminated with the coronavirus as a result of she commonly drinks cow urine.

Earlier Hindu Mahasabha chief Swami Chakrapani Maharaj and Sanjay Gupta, a Bharatiya Janata Get together (BJP) legislator within the state of Uttar Pradesh had additionally made related claims concerning cow’s urine and dung.

When interviewed on this topic, Dr Shailendra Saxena, of the Indian Virological Society, informed BBC Information: “There isn’t any medical proof to indicate that cow urine has anti-viral traits.” 

However no motion has been taken towards Pragya Thakur or another BJP chief for deceptive individuals, making fraudulent claims and indulging in quackery.

The Central Authorities’s Ministry of Ayush (Determine 4 above) has been recommending using some pure concoctions to combat Covid 19. Once more in accordance with Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at Yale College, many of those claims should not grounded in proof.

It’s price noting that a number of of those suggestions/treatments (eg, consuming heat water – or gargling with vinegar or salt options) have been discredited by the Indian authorities’s fact-checking service.


Modi and his BJP colleagues in New Delhi and Gujarat organised big super-spreader occasions (known as “Namaste Trump”) in the course of the first wave of the Covid-19 pandemic to welcome President Trump.

As a substitute of studying from such errors which resulted in lots of hundreds of deaths, the Modi Administration inspired the Election Commissioner of India to carry elections for the state legislature in West Bengal and Assam.

That is despite the truth that below Article 172(1) of the Indian Structure, the Election Commissioner (EC) of India is empowered to postpone an election in case of a state of Emergency, for one yr at a time along with a interval of six months after the Emergency is lifted.

But the Modi Authorities inspired the EC to begin electioneering for West Bengal and Assam Legislatures on March 27 as a result of it was assured of its win in West Bengal. So politicians from all events held election rallies over the next weeks.

The BJP and its stalwarts didn’t stop the arrival of huge crowds (operating into a number of million pilgrims) for the Kumbh Mela. The latter is a non secular competition lasting 12 days throughout which large crowds collect to wash within the River Ganga both at Allahabad or Haridwar. The pilgrims begin arriving as early as 2 weeks upfront. The Kumbh Mela 2021 occurred at Haridwar. This turned one other big super-spreader occasion. A half-hearted effort to advise individuals to not come was solely made after a number of Hindu mendicants succumbed to Covid-19.

I simply give yet one more instance the place Modi was personally concerned. On April 17 at an election rally in Asansol, whereas campaigning for West Bengal Legislative Meeting, Modi firing up his viewers stated: “Have by no means seen such an enormous crowd at a rally”.

At none of those occasions neither any social distance was adopted nor individuals had been carrying masks.


Modi, similar to Trump, has been eager to affiliate himself with optimistic developments. Like Trump, who demanded that Covid-19 aid cheques despatched out to struggling households should bear his signature, equally, Indians who’ve been vaccinated obtain a certificates that bears Modi’s headshot.

A charity set as much as entice donations from the general public to supply aid to Covid -19 victims is named, Prime Minister’s Citizen Help and Aid in Emergency Conditions Fund and is abbreviated as “PM CARES.”

One other factor frequent between Trump and Modi and different BJP leaders is, because the above dialogue has proven, that every one of them lie incessantly.

Within the foregoing passages, I gave some examples of mendacity by the BJP leaders together with Prime Minister Modi. I additionally listed many examples of clamping down on COVID-19 victims and their households for expressing their grievances and distress. I detailed to what extent the Modi Administration might have been under-reporting the COVID-19 deaths and what strategies it employed in order that the utmost variety of COVID-19 fatalities might be excluded from the rely.

Maybe probably the most telling and scathing criticism of the Modi Administration got here from The Lancet, some of the prestigious medical journals on the planet which was compelled to enterprise into the political enviornment.

The BJP and its leaders’ obsession with picture administration and their efforts to suppress the reality have so alarmed the editors of The Lancet that in an editorial in its situation of Could 8, 2021, it was compelled to vent its anger and frustration on how the Modi Authorities was extra fascinated with indulging spin-doctoring and picture administration than serving to the Covid-19 victims.

The Lancet quoting the Institute for Well being Metrics and Analysis (which estimated that India will in all probability see 1 million deaths from COVID-19 by finish of July) editorialized “If that consequence had been to occur, Modi’s Authorities can be accountable for presiding over a self-inflicted nationwide disaster.”

The Lancet wrote: “At instances, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Authorities has appeared extra intent on eradicating criticism on Twitter than making an attempt to manage the pandemic.”

Referring to super-spreader occasions (a few of which I’ve talked about above), The Lancet wrote: “Regardless of warnings in regards to the dangers of super-spreader occasions, the federal government allowed spiritual festivals to go forward, drawing hundreds of thousands of individuals from across the nation, together with large political rallies — conspicuous for his or her lack of COVID-19 mitigation measures.”

Noticing the collapse of the well being infrastructure, The Lancet castigated the Modi Authorities thus:

“The scenes of struggling in India are laborious to grasp… hospitals are overwhelmed, and well being employees are exhausted and changing into contaminated. Social media is filled with determined individuals (docs and the general public) in search of medical oxygen, hospital beds, and different requirements. But earlier than the second wave of circumstances of COVID-19 started to mount in early March, Indian Minister of Well being Harsh Vardhan declared that India was within the “endgame” of the epidemic.”

The Lancet additionally excoriated the Modi Authorities for its botched vaccination programme.


From the above dialogue and my article of 6 Could 2020 printed right here it should be clear that although New Delhi had loads of warning earlier than the primary wave struck India, it didn’t use that point to organize for the pandemic. It didn’t cancel “Namaste Trump” rallies. As a substitute, it took pleasure in the truth that every rally was attended by a whole lot of hundreds of individuals.

At house it continued to play its divisive politics by demonising individuals who had been protesting towards the Residents’ Modification Act (CAA) and Nationwide Register of Residents (NRC) – each these legislative initiatives are primarily geared toward Indian Muslims and different non-Hindu minorities. It hoped its divisive politics and the hatred it had tried to generate towards Indian Muslims will assist it to wrest treasury benches in West Bengal from Mamata Banerjee’s Trinamool Congress.

The Modi administration ensured that the second wave will likely be extra fierce by organising many super-spreader occasions within the type of election rallies (politicians of different events additionally helped on this endeavour), and by permitting the Kumbh Competition to go forward at Haridwar.

Below strain from its electoral base, it additionally allowed the financial exercise to start too early, actually earlier than the primary wave had been introduced below management. This was exacerbated by the truth that it by no means carried out sufficient checks to find out the extent of virus transmission inside the group.

However two extra components have additionally performed a much bigger function:

First, the extra well being infrastructure that was arrange to deal with the primary wave of the Covid 19 pandemic was dismantled. This was finished in most states though the authorities should have identified that nations like Spain, Italy, Britain, and many others. had been affected by the second and third waves of the pandemic.

Let me offer you just a few random examples.

Final yr, 4 non permanent hospitals had been arrange in New Delhi. They had been dismantled in February this yr and needed to be erected once more.

In response to the Uttar Pradesh authorities it arrange 503 Covid hospitals with 150,000 beds to deal with the primary wave of the pandemic. [Note: Any claim that Yogi Adityanath makes must be taken with a grain of salt. He has a very flexible relationship with the truth. For him, truth is what he says and not what the evidence may suggest.]

However by February 2021, it had solely had 83 hospitals this with 17,000.

The Rajendra Institute of Medical Sciences in Ranchi is the most important government-run hospital within the state of Jharkhand. It doesn’t have a single high-resolution CT scan machine. Now the state authorities has been ordered by the Excessive Court docket to treatment the scenario.

Karnataka, some of the severely affected states, added solely 18 intensive care items with ventilators in the course of the first wave. No further capability was added in the course of the second wave.

In different phrases, regardless of what a part of India one concentrates on, one will get a powerful impression that it was neither ready for the primary wave nor the second wave although all of the indicators of an impending second wave had been there.

Why the forms in New Delhi couldn’t foresee the approaching catastrophe regardless of many flashing warning indicators?

The explanations could be discovered if one is aware of a bit of bit how Mr Modi and the BJP function. For many authorities positions – whether or not be it a senior government place or that of a lowly clerk, desire is given to those that have strong BJP or RSS (BJP’s guardian organisation) credentials. These appointments should not primarily based on advantage, {qualifications} or high quality of feat in earlier roles. Individuals appointed for his or her loyalty to the Hindutva trigger and the BJP and what have finished previously to advertise the BJP and RSS manifesto.

In states like Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat, and many others. it’s tough to get a job whilst a peon except the particular person is a BJP or RSS member or shares their Hindutva ideology. (Warning: please don’t confuse BJP’s Hindutva ideology with Hinduism. They’re two very various things.)

Additional, Mr Modi has centralised decision-making. All necessary choices are made in his workplace. As we all know from his speech to the World Financial Discussion board, he turned a sufferer of his personal vanity or hubris.


We have no idea the precise extent of group transmission. If we take the outcomes of serum surveys carried out within the slums of Mumbai and the extent of an infection in such a really distant village as Karma Gondi as our standards then it will appear that it might be within the order of 40% to 50%.

We all know that the coronavirus has penetrated rural India the place not solely well being care services are nearly non-existent however half of India’s rural inhabitants doesn’t even have entry to wash water.

As a result of the group transmission has been allowed to happen on such a large scale and for therefore lengthy, the unique SARS-CoV-2 virus has mutated many instances. A few of these mutants are extra deadly and simply transmissible. The virologists on the Centre for Mobile and Molecular Biology (CCMB), Bangalore, have recognized a brand new variant of SARS-CoV-2 – ‘N440K’.

Dr Divya Tej Sowpati of CCMB has estimated that this new variant is 15 instances extra deadly than the sooner ones. It’s this variant that has prompted havoc and numerous fatalities in Andhra Pradesh in the previous couple of months.

It is vitally tough to say when would the third wave arrive (if it arrives in any respect) and the way ferocious or gentle would it not be? All of this can rely upon which mutant turns into dominant and the way deadly it’s? It could additionally depend on what share of the inhabitants has been vaccinated.

Allow us to hope, the Indian Authorities will be capable of put its act collectively very quickly. It must do the next issues concurrently:

  • Procure sufficient doses of vaccines;
  • Prepare sufficient nurses and first well being care employees in order that no less than all of the 20+ years previous adults could be inoculated;
  • It should educate Indians to beat vaccine hesitancy. Some individuals are reluctant to be vaccinated (even in city areas) as a result of they worry the vaccine will both hasten their loss of life or render them impotent. It must run properly focused instructional programmes and commercials to counter such fears.
  • All nurses and first well being care employees accountable for administering the vaccine will should be educated in order that they’ll reply any questions that folks may put to them.

The Modi Administration might want to study to cease giving combined messages. If it needs individuals to have faith within the vaccines, then it should crack down laborious on BJP MPs and RSS officers and functionaries and Hindu mendicants and clergymen who take pleasure in deceptive data and quackery, eg, by consuming cow urine one could be cured of COVID-19 an infection (Pragya Thakur), or patently false and absurd statements made by Baba Ramdev, a distinguished BJP and RSS sympathizer, and many others. In a video clip that went viral, Baba Ramdev stated: “Lakhs [hundreds of thousands] have died from taking allopathic medicines for COVID-19.”


Vidya S. Sharma advises shoppers on nation dangers and technology-based joint ventures. He has contributed quite a few articles for such prestigious newspapers as: The Canberra Instances, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age (Melbourne), The Australian Monetary Evaluate, The Financial Instances (India), The Enterprise Normal (India), EU Reporter (Brusells), East Asia Discussion board (Canberra), The Enterprise Line (Chennai, India), The Hindustan Instances (India), The Monetary Specific (India), The Day by day Caller (US). He could be contacted at: [email protected]Supply:

Related Articles

Back to top button